CO129-137 - Sir MacDonnell - 1869 [4-5] — Page 375

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Circumstances of this place and it's reputation make it a plain duty to consider simply whether the proposed appointment would or would not advance British interests, seeing that there is no privilege which had ever been urged by the Chinese Authorities, and that the necessity for a Chinese Consul had never been experienced by either the Sovereign or Native Community.

I can only conceive such an officer being useful in one way, viz.: to save the delay of reference to Canton by at once backing warrants for the arrest of Criminals or other parties amenable to British Law, who might have escaped to the Mainland. Even in that respect a Consul would not be half so useful as the Mandarin at Kowloon, who is in daily correspondence with the Hong Kong Police.

Altogether, neither I nor my Colleagues, nor the representatives of the commercial and general interests of Hong Kong in the Legislative Council, are able to see in what manner the legitimate interests of either Great Britain or China are to be benefited by adopting this most unnecessary and uncalled for suggestion of Sir M. Alcock. We believe that such a creation of an "imperium in imperio" would produce alarm and dissatisfaction amongst Chinese residents here, and that by unnecessarily...

Page 18

F.O. 2259, 636-2354, 1114 June 1869.

Edit History

2026-05-20 04:25:05 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Circumstances of this place and it's reputation make it a plain duty to consider simply whether the proposed appointment would or would not advance British interests, seeing that there is no privilege which had ever been urged by the Chinese Authorities, and that the necessity for a Chinese Consul had never been experienced by either the Sovereign or Native Community.I can only conceive such an officer being useful in one way, viz.: to save the delay of reference to Canton by at once backing warrants for the arrest of Criminals or other parties amenable to British Law, who might have escaped to the Mainland. Even in that respect a Consul would not be half so useful as the Mandarin at Kowloon, who is in daily correspondence with the Hong Kong Police.Altogether, neither I nor my Colleagues, nor the representatives of the commercial and general interests of Hong Kong in the Legislative Council, are able to see in what manner the legitimate interests of either Great Britain or China are to be benefited by adopting this most unnecessary and uncalled for suggestion of Sir M. Alcock. We believe that such a creation of an "imperium in imperio" would produce alarm and dissatisfaction amongst Chinese residents here, and that by unnecessarily...Page 18F.O. 2259, 636-2354, 1114 June 1869.
Baseline (Original)
14}C3710circumstances of this place and it's preputationit.was a plain duty to consider simply whether the proposed appointment would or would not advance Brition interests, beeing that there is no privilege, which had rightto claim thenever been urged by the tahinese Authorities, and that the necepity for a bhinese bonaut had mever been experienced by either the Serign Native Community17Scan only only conceive such an officer ww.omeeing useful in way viz: to save the delay of reference to banten by at once backing wanants for the arrest of Criminals ar other parties amenable to Brition Law, who might have excciped toplurking oar be the Mainland. Even in thatbonoul respect a bonand would not be half so useful as the Mandarin at howloon, who lide furt to heary despite the views of fir Rutherford on thefof State 636-1114 Juny 1869.22596362354F.O.exsubject, ina necefitate rei inalmost daily |correspundence with the Hong Kong Felice. 18. Altogether neither I men my Cocecutivenon the representatives of the commercialwhatin and general interests of Hong Kong the Legislative Council, are able to see in manner the legitimate interests of either Great Britain or China are to be benefitted by adapting this mest nume spany and uncalled for puggestion of Sir M. Abeack. We believe that such a creation of an "imperium in imperic" would produce alarm and dissatisfaction amongst Chinese residents here, and that by unnecefparily
2026-05-20 04:25:05 · Baseline
View content

14

}

C

3710

circumstances of this place and it's preputation

it.

was a

plain duty to consider simply

whether the proposed appointment would

or would not advance Brition interests,

beeing that there is no privilege, which had

right

to claim the

never

been urged

by the tahinese Authorities, and that the necepity for a bhinese bonaut had

mever

been experienced by either the Serign

Native Community

17

Scan only

only conceive such an officer

ww.ome

eing useful in

way viz: to save the delay of reference to banten by at once backing wanants for the arrest of Criminals ar other parties amenable to Brition Law, who might have excciped to plurking o

ar be

the Mainland. Even in that

bonoul

respect a bonand would not be half so

useful

as the Mandarin at howloon, who

lide furt to heary despite the views of fir Rutherford on the

fof State 636-

1114 Juny 1869.

2259

636

2354

F.O.

ex

subject, ina necefitate rei in almost daily |

correspundence with the Hong Kong Felice. 18. Altogether neither I men

my

Cocecutive

non the representatives of the commercial

what

in

and general interests of Hong Kong the Legislative Council, are able to see in

manner the legitimate interests of either Great Britain or China are to be benefitted by adapting this mest nume spany and uncalled for puggestion of Sir M. Abeack. We believe that such a creation of an "imperium in imperic" would produce alarm and dissatisfaction amongst Chinese residents here, and that by unnecefparily

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.